Tuesday, July 14, 2026

Fan Sites, Love Letters and Likes: How We Learned to Make Money on the Internet

 


There was a time when the internet wasn’t really about making money.

That sounds strange today, especially to younger readers who have grown up in a world of influencers, sponsorships, subscriptions, premium tiers, affiliate links, paid newsletters, and endless reminders to “like, share and subscribe.” But for many of us who first logged onto the web in the mid-1990s, money wasn’t the point.

Curiosity was.

Community was.

The internet wasn’t yet a marketplace.

It was a frontier.

The Early Internet

When I first began exploring the web, simply owning a website was unusual. Personal domain names were rare. Most ordinary people didn’t even know how websites worked, let alone how to build one.

The internet belonged largely to hobbyists, programmers, university students, and enthusiasts.

If you loved StarCraft, you built a StarCraft strategy page.

If you loved Wing Commander, you built a Wing Commander fan site.

If you loved photography, trains, astronomy, or tropical fish, chances are someone had already spent hundreds of unpaid hours creating a little corner of the web dedicated to that passion.

These weren’t businesses.

They were love letters.

The reward wasn’t a monthly subscription.

The reward was finding someone, somewhere in the world who loved the same strange thing you did.

That was enough.

The First Internet Careers

Of course, people still made money.

Just differently.

The obvious winners were the web developers.

If you knew HTML, JavaScript, Perl, PHP, or CGI, companies suddenly needed you. Every business wanted a website, and very few people knew how to build one.

A talented web developer could build websites for law firms, restaurants, schools, charities, local businesses, or whoever happened to knock on the door.

They weren’t becoming internet celebrities.

They were becoming skilled tradespeople in an entirely new industry.

Others sold software.

Some created shareware.

Others reviewed books or computer hardware and eventually earned tiny affiliate commissions when someone bought something through a link.

Banner advertising slowly appeared.

Google AdSense would eventually arrive.

Most sites made very little.

Many barely earned enough to pay for hosting.

That was okay.

Making a living online was still the exception rather than the expectation.

Communities Instead of Platforms

One thing I miss from those years isn’t the technology.

It’s the neighborhoods.

Every major game seemed to have its own forums.

Every fan site had its own personality.

Every community developed its own inside jokes, traditions, moderators, local celebrities, and culture.

Logging into a game’s official forum felt like walking into your favorite local coffee shop.

You recognized people.

You remembered old conversations.

Arguments continued for years.

Friendships formed.

Today, much of that has migrated to Reddit.

That isn’t necessarily bad.

Reddit solved real problems.

Companies no longer needed to build, host, moderate, and legally manage enormous discussion forums. Instead, millions of conversations could happen under one roof with sophisticated moderation tools and enormous audiences.

It was efficient.

But something quietly disappeared.

The neighborhood became the city.

The little fan sites slowly vanished.

The love letters became apartment buildings.

Then Came Monetization

None of this happened because someone became greedy overnight.

The internet simply grew up.

As audiences grew larger, opportunities appeared.

People realized they could earn a living making videos.

Writing newsletters.

Teaching courses.

Reviewing products.

Streaming games.

Producing podcasts.

The creator economy exploded.

In many ways, this was wonderful.

Talented people who once struggled to find an audience suddenly could.

Artists no longer needed galleries.

Writers no longer needed publishers.

Musicians no longer needed record labels.

For many creators, this democratization has been life-changing.

But something else grew alongside it.

Friction.

Today, one creator might have:

  • a YouTube channel,

  • a TikTok account,

  • a podcast,

  • a newsletter,

  • a Discord server,

  • a Patreon,

  • affiliate links,

  • sponsors,

  • merchandise,

  • premium memberships,

  • online courses,

  • exclusive livestreams,

  • and several different social media platforms.

None of these are inherently bad.

Many creators genuinely enjoy building these ecosystems.

But it is remarkable how much of today’s internet revolves around not just creating value, but managing increasingly complex ways of receiving it.

The New Currency

Ironically, the internet has always traded in roughly the same currencies.

Only the proportions have changed.

In the 1990s, people often accumulated:

  • reputation,

  • friendships,

  • knowledge,

  • community,

  • and status.

Money came later, if it came at all.

Today, many creators understandably begin by asking how something can be monetized.

Again, this isn’t a criticism.

If someone creates real value, there is nothing wrong with being rewarded for it.

The internet simply matured into an economy.

The surprising thing is how many of its original gifts still remain beneath the surface.

Some Things Never Changed

The internet is still remarkably good at helping unusual people find one another.

Someone fascinated by medieval swords.

Someone restoring antique radios.

Someone documenting birds on their apartment balcony.

Someone explaining little-known mechanics in a twenty-year-old video game.

None of these audiences need to be enormous.

They simply need to exist.

The internet still excels at connecting people through shared curiosity.

Perhaps that’s why so many of the most memorable communities weren’t built by marketers.

They were built by enthusiasts.

The technology has changed.

The business models have changed.

The algorithms have changed.

But genuine enthusiasm still has a way of finding its audience.

Looking Forward

I don’t think the future belongs exclusively to giant influencers or tiny hobbyists.

It probably belongs to both.

Some creators will build enormous media businesses.

Others will quietly cultivate communities of a few hundred or a few thousand people who simply enjoy gathering around a shared interest.

That may sound old-fashioned.

In a way, it is.

Because beneath all the subscriptions, platforms, algorithms, and monetization strategies, the internet still remembers what it was built for.

Helping people who care deeply about something discover that they are not alone.

And perhaps that has always been its most valuable product—one that no algorithm, platform, or business model has ever managed to replace.

No comments:

Post a Comment